Subscribe to the Magazine
Members:
Funky, Tart Flavors of Belgian Beer
Fri, 06/26/2009 - 11:10pm — Carolyn-Smagalski
I love those funky, tart flavors that Brettanomyces imparts in Belgian beer. Not everybody does. Do you think people who like Belgian-style beer have a natural affinity that draws them to it, or do they develop a sophistication that craves this diversity over time?
Do you think it is more common to see wine drinkers accepting the flavors of Belgian beer more readily than hard-core beer drinkers? Are lager drinkers less inclined to like Brett?


Belgian Sours
Interesting question....
I'm one of those guys who really likes the sours. Probably started with kriek lambic, then gueze. (I had a beer store owner GIVE me some geuze he had around, saying it's undrinkable garbage - wouldn't even offer it for sale. I said "thank you" and took it off his hands) There's something enticing in the sourness, and even the mustiness: the things that turn other people off ;)
My usual beer taste favors a malt profile: not too much of a hops guy. My wine tastes run to the big, bold, and dry. My whisky tastes go to single barrel, single malt, and cask strength. Tea? Lapsang souchong. Maybe there's a correlation to what I like in Belgian brews :D
My best guess is that people have preferential tasting profiles, some may be genetic; some may be experiential; some may just be "I don't like that." Some people love brussel sprouts, and some find them repellant. My other best guess is that saying "sophistication craves diversity" may be a stand-alone (and profound) observation.
Funky Beers
I think it's a bit of both. I have introduced people who mainly drink American lagers and the occational Hacker-Pschorr Weisse to Belgian's with a fine Gueuze, and some just love it and others hate it. I also have known a few fellow beer geeks who hated sour beers, but I run into them a year later and they are sour and funky freaks.To be honest I don't understand the comment about wine drinkers. From my experience I don't know any difference between wine drinkers and beer drinkers when it comes to accepting flavors. If you mean hard core bear drinkers, such as beer geeks, I think they are going to be more accepting of the beer styles, even if they are sour than the wine drinker. If you mean hard core beer drinker, by meaning those who guzzel 12 cans of Busch light in a night, then no, they will not be as accepting of anything other than their Light Lager. Again, with the last statement, Lager encompasses many styles, you can have an Eisbock which is a lager, and is very rich and complex, or a hoppy Bohemian Pilsner, or an American lager. Having a specific disposition to a lager or ale style, in my eyes, will have no bearing on a person's acceptance of a particular flavor profile of a beer.I don't particularly enjoy heffe's. I am not a fan of the clove phenol that is usually promenent in that beer style. However, there are a few heffe's I do like even though as a whole I don't enjoy that flavor characteristic. So ina sense, how recepetive someone is of the brett flavor and aroma, can also have to do with the level at which they are presented it too.In the end, I don't think there is any particular group that would be more receptive than another, just like with all tasting matters, it is very subjective and more an individual taste matter than anything.
I know you drank it, but did you experience the beer?
Brett
For me Brett-based beers either taste like sweet earthy-graham-crackers OR and old tennis sneaker buried under a chicken-coop. I've had a few I liked and a few more that I couldn't drink. I know belgian beer lovers (myself included) that still dislike the Brett beers so I'm not sure it helps.With Merlot-barred-aged beers all over the place, I see the perfect open door for wine-lovers to try some good beers.Lager yeasts are way different from Brett-based beers so I'm not sure there's much there to correlate.
mybeerbuzz.com